Hunter McKnight chose not to use his Immunity Idol, and then got voted out of ‘Survivor 46.’
The Big Picture
-
Survivor
‘s Immunity Idols can make or break a game: use them wisely. - Sharing idol locations leads to targets on your back.
- Being strategic with idol information is crucial in Survivor.
The Immunity Idol is one of the most powerful and lasting twists Survivor has ever introduced. For some, it burns a hole in their pocket. For others, it’s their last line of defense. But nothing is worse than being blindsided and walking out of the Tribal Council without it ever being used. The latest victim of the unused idol was Survivor 46‘s Hunter McKnight. Hunter left in pure shock and with utter heartbreak. Pulling the trigger on using the idol correctly takes precision, but holding onto it can lead to immense regret. Many castaways have tried hard to conceal and keep their idol a secret, but once its location is out in the open, your game changes. A target is immediately formed. For Hunter, had he not shared his secret, his target wouldn’t have been as large, and he could have used it to his advantage. Loose lips do in fact sink ships.
The New Era of Survivor has introduced a plethora of new twists and mechanics, but the Hidden Immunity Idol has had a lasting impression on the game. As one of the most sought after advantages in the game, the Immunity Idol has played a major part in how many players have set their game strategy around finding it and using it as leverage in the game. Since it was introduced in Survivor: Guatemala, its power has forever changed the game. Games have been won and games have been destroyed thanks to the idol.
Survivor
A reality show where a group of contestants are stranded in a remote location with little more than the clothes on their back. The lone survivor of this contest takes home a million dollars.
- Release Date
- May 31, 2000
- Cast
- Jeff Probst
- Main Genre
- Reality-TV
- Seasons
- 46
- Studio
- CBS
- Creator(s)
- Charlie Parsons
The History of the Hidden Immunity Idol
Implemented in Survivor‘s eleventh season, the Hidden Immunity Idol originally served as something similar to the Individual Immunity Necklace. Like many other devices in the game, it has evolved to be an advantage that, when used during Tribal Council, would negate votes against the user. The idol can only be used once and, often times, it will be re-placed into the game for the original user or other castaways to go out and find them again. In the New Era of Survivor, the idol has been tied to a Beware Advantage, a mechanic that forces the finder to engage in a mini-challenge first. The idol usually has an experiment date in the game. The ticking time bomb aspect raises the stakes as it forces the owner to play it at the right time before it’s too late. With the element having never left the game, to spook other players in the game, certain castaways have created fake idols to create chaos and force others to think they have one of their own to utilize. On paper, having a Hidden Immunity Idol can change a player’s game, but how it affects them is truly the game changer.
Many games have been completely obliterated because of their Hidden Immunity Idol. One of the most infamous and dramatic blindsides that featured an unused idol was during Survivor: China. James Clement, a physical powerhouse, had his hands on not one, but two idols. With his threat level so high, his allies, led by season winner Todd Herzog, orchestrated a brilliant blindside of James. Ensuring him that he was safe prevented James from having any inclination that he was in danger, and thus, James walked out with an idol in each pocket. On Survivor: Micronesia, a true legend of the game, Ozzy Lusth had an idol that he decided not to play as he felt there was a target in front of him. Cirie Fields took Ozzy’s lack of individual immunity win as the chance to pull the trigger on Ozzy and his overconfidence. Ozzy was eliminated from the game and set up the rivalry that came into play years later on Survivor: Game Changers. Speaking of Survivor: Game Changers, JT Thomas, the winner of Survivor: Tocantins, was one of the few winners back on the season.
‘Survivor’ Needs to Bring Back Players In the New Era
Since the New Era began in Season 41, only one castaway has returned for a second chance. We need more!
The Danger of Sharing Too Much Information on ‘Survivor’
After a wild joint Tribal Council saw super fan favorite Malcolm Freiberg blindsided, two-time winner Sandra Diaz-Twine sought revenge on JT. And when the queen has a goal, she fulfills it. JT walked out of the game with an idol in his pocket using his silly sugar-based rivalry with Michaela Bradshaw as a guise to keep him comfortable. Kelley Wentworth was one of the surprise players that impressed fans during Survivor: Cambodia. During her run on the season, Kelley managed to make a brilliant idol play that kept her in the game. When she came back again on Survivor: Edge of Extinction, she played confidently, becoming the last of the four returning players left in the game. But once a brilliant idol player, Kelley turned into another casualty of an unused idol as her allies decided to oust her in a crushing blindside. And TheShockNews goes on and on. At the end of the day, being lulled into a false sense of security can cause an idol to go unplayed. But that tends to happen when others know the location of something that should be left secret.
From the start of Survivor 46, Hunter McKnight has been a clear front-runner to win the season. He had been called Survivor McGuyver by his tribe mates. He had been seen crafting camp items that no other player ever dreamed of inventing. He even made a bed that sounded like a bed! Hunter’s love for Survivor caused him to create at-home versions of Survivor challenges, some of which he allowed his students to play. His passion for Survivor was evident, though don’t ask him to put his knowledge of the history of the show to the test. He failed at that. Before the three tribes came together, he was able to officially locate his Hidden Immunity Idol on his beach, an item he held close to his chest. That is until his back was against the wall. Thanks Q! To save himself, he tried to push the vote over toward Q Burdette, who, just 24 hours prior, asked his tribe mates to vote him out. To ensure his safety, he shared with his rivals that he had an Immunity Idol that he was planning on using. With Tiffany Nicole Ervin‘s own Immunity Idol exposed by Q, both individuals had threatened to use their idols to ensure their safety. Sadly for Hunter, after losing the Immunity Challenge, he was lulled into a false sense of security in order to not use his idol. In the end, following a tie vote, Hunter was eliminated, and his idol was flushed out of the game. His wrong call led to his blindside. He was in pure shock. Had he not revealed his idol, he could have used it to blindside the rest of the tribe, causing Q to be the victim. Alas, the agent of chaos still remains and the Nami tribe has its third straight member on the jury.
‘Survivor 46’s Castmate Hunter’s Misjudgment Cost Him
The biggest struggle a player can endure is when to divulge information to other players in the game. Whether it’s their alliance members or rivals they are trying to protect themselves against, saying the wrong thing can be your entire undoing. With so many players having a giant Survivor bucket list, finding an idol can rank quite high, and you want to gloat about it. But once the knowledge is out there, that’s the power that can alter your entire game. Armchair fans scream at their televisions when castaways spill the beans about their idols and their advantages. They know how dangerous that could be. But can you fault a player for wanting to share their success with someone who is not holding a camera? Though it hasn’t been seen in recent seasons, the Knowledge is Power advantage has exemplified just how dangerous sharing knowledge can be. Since it was introduced in Survivor 41, it’s caused many players to be hesitant about revealing the locations of certain items in the game. And even if the Knowledge is Power is not in a specific season, players know the threat could be out there.
Survivor is one of the most brilliant games because, no matter if the game is always the same, a different group of individuals can truly define how the game mechanics are played. In some instances, sharing your idol with allies is the best thing for your game. In another, your ally could use this information against you. But what remains true, keeping important information to yourself in the game of Survivor is always the best plan of action. Hunter was poised to go long in Survivor 46, but a series of errors, from himself and certain allies, caused his downfall. Hopefully, future players can learn from Hunter’s mistake when they find themselves out on the islands of Fiji.
Survivor 46 airs Wednesday at 8 pm EST on CBS. All seasons of Survivor are available to stream on Paramount+.
This article was originally published on collider.com