Landing the overall best spot for 2024 is the Kush High Volume Mascara from Milk Makeup. Equipped with a sturdy, thick brush, this mascara created a volumized, striking look that could be played down for an everyday appearance or amped up for something more dramatic. I found that it also lasted throughout the day without smudging or flaking, which is a must-have when it comes to mascara. In addition to the great look, the formula contains hemp seep oil, which is intended to nourish and condition lashes.
Milk Makeup also gets points for its sustainability. Though Better Goods reports that its environmental impact could be improved, with the company typically using single-use plastic containers, its products are 100% vegan and cruelty-free. According to its website, the brand is also striving to make its shipping packaging more eco-friendly, opting, for example, to use inner-bag materials made of 100% consumer waste. Of course, the price point here makes this mascara a bit higher end than the other choices, but I absolutely love this product.
Purchase the Milk Makeup Kush High Volume Mascara for $28 at Milk Makeup.