Kelsey Anderson of 'The Bachelor' Told Us Her Top Holiday Gift Picks, Including Her ‘Holy Grail’ Hair Secret

Listen up, Bachelor nation! We got the inside scoop on Kelsey Anderson’s top gift recommendations for the holiday season — and they’re all available with speedy shipping for Amazon Prime members. 

The Bachelor star created a holiday gift guide with Amazon’s Buy with Prime program, which allows Prime subscribers to shop at participating stores with the same benefits they know and love at Amazon, even if they’re not shopping there. Prime members can expect fast and free shipping, 24-hour live chat support, easy returns, and even more perks outside of Amazon.

When it comes to her collaboration with Amazon, Anderson tells PEOPLE, “It’s the convenience aspect for me. I love being so busy and constantly on the go and then being able to get things so fast. I think that’s the luxury of Buy with Prime.” 

Anderson gave us the rundown on her absolute favorite picks in the gift guide, which include her “holy grail” for haircare and some fashion favorites of fiancé Joey Graziade. Best of all, prices start at just $23.

Shop Kelsey Anderson’s Holiday Gift Picks

• Kelsey’s Hair “Holy Grail”: Igk First Class Charcoal Detox Dry Shampoo, $32; amazon.com and igkhair.com
• Caitlyn Minimalist Amelia Duo Hoop Earrings, $25–$36; amazon.com and caitlynminimalist.com
• Joey’s Gift Pick: Hey Dude Paul Loafers in Nut, $80; amazon.com and heydude.com
• Buxom Plump Shot Lip-Plumping Lip Serum, $29; amazon.com and buxomcosmetics.com
• Jlab Go Air True Wireless Earbuds, $25; amazon.com and jlab.com
• Ultrean 4.2-Quart Air Fryer, $70; amazon.com
• Igk Crybaby Anti-Frizz Serum, $32; amazon.com and igkhair.com
• Under-$25 Favorite: Bare Minerals Strength and Length Eyebrow Gel, $23; amazon.com and bareminerals.com
• Elizabeth Arden Eight Hour Skin Cream, $35; amazon.com and elizabetharden.com
• Bearaby Velvet Napper Weighted Blanket, $259; amazon.com and bearaby.com

Igk First Class Charcoal Detox Dry Shampoo

No, Kelsey Anderson’s ultra-voluminous hair isn’t held up by magic. She told PEOPLE, “One of my secrets is I only wash my hair once a week, and dry shampoo is my holy grail.” Her absolute favorite is this Igk First Class Detox Dry Shampoo, which is formulated with charcoal powder to absorb oil and eliminate odor, as well as white tea powder to soothe the scalp. 

Caitlyn Minimalist Amelia Duo Hoop Earrings

Anderson also admitted that she’s “bad at buying [herself] jewelry,” so receiving it as a gift is always the preferred option. She highlighted a couple of styles from Caitlyn Minimalist that would be “perfect for gifting to the women in your life” in her gift guide, and we’re obsessed with these understated yet eye-catching earrings. They give the illusion of two hoops but are actually adjoined at the post, and they’re made from durable sterling silver with an 18-carat gold finish.

Hey Dude Paul Loafers in Nut

Joey Graziadei’s love for a “comfortable, easy shoe” inspired Anderson to include these Hey Dude loafers in her gift guide. They have a foam insole, a rubber outsole for traction, and adjustable laces to help find the ideal fit. In addition to their comfort, the shoes are outfitted with faux leather and suede that can pair with casual or formal outfits. If you’re looking for similar styles, check out PEOPLE’s picks for the best slip-on shoes this year. 

Kelsey Anderson’s holiday gift guide is chock-full of clever products you can get ASAP, thanks to Amazon’s Buy with Prime program. Keep scrolling to see even more standouts from the curation.

Bare Minerals Strength and Length Eyebrow Gel

Buxom Plump Shot Lip-Plumping Lip Serum

Jlab Go Air True Wireless Earbuds

Ultrean 4.2-Quart Air Fryer

Igk Crybaby Anti-Frizz Serum

Elizabeth Arden Eight Hour Skin Cream

Bearaby Velvet Napper Weighted Blanket

Izod Performance Golf Grid Polo Shirt

K18 Leave-In Molecular Hair Mask,

Caitlyn Minimalist Diamond Drop Huggie Earrings

Beachwaver S-Series Rotating Curling Iron

Truff Gourmet Hot Sauce Best-Seller Pack